Skip to main content
The Candied Anchor, ice cream stop in Montauk
Photo 1 of 5
Photo: Google Maps
Ice Cream & Treats

The Candied Anchor

📍 Montauk, NY
4.6(29 Google)
🕐
Hours
  • Monday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Thursday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Friday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Sunday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
🗓️ Add to My Plan →

The Candied Anchor is a 1950s-style sweet shop at 721 Main Street in Montauk, where you can introduce the grandkids to old favorites like Mary Janes and strawberry Charleston Chews. Shelves also hold ice cream, baked treats from local baker Dawn Rennar such as brownies and decorated sugar cookies, and quirky retro gifts. If a birthday is coming up, they carry party supplies and home-made piñatas.

Plan with current information

Hours, prices, programs, and accessibility can change. Confirm time-sensitive details with the venue before leaving.

Grandparent-Friendly Details

Noise level
Usually moderate noise
Typical visit
Usually about 30min

Typical for this kind of place. Not recorded for this venue.

Fun Things to Do Here

Ideas to make the most of your visit to The Candied Anchor

Flavor Prediction
Before ordering, each person secretly predicts what flavor the others will pick. Reveal after the order.
Ice Cream Critic
Describe your ice cream like a food critic: "Notes of summer, a hint of nostalgia..." Grandkids love this.
Ice Cream Alphabet
Go around naming ice cream flavors A to Z. No repeating. It gets hard after M.
Dream Flavor
Everyone invents their ultimate ice cream flavor combination. The wildest one wins — you decide.
Memory Round
Each person shares one ice cream memory while eating. Where were you? Who else was there?

Budget & Insider Tips

Grandparent Money Tips
  • •Single scoops are usually plenty — grandkids' eyes are bigger than their stomachs with ice cream. Start small and work up.
  • •Weekday afternoons skip the weekend line and sometimes come with daily specials — ask if there's a flavor of the day.
  • •Many shops offer a "kid's size" smaller than the small that's not on the menu. Worth asking.

Share this place

Want more places like this?

Get the free weekly guide: top 5 grandkid-friendly spots every Friday, across Fairfield County, Westchester & Long Island.

Community Posts

#GrandkidsGuideApproved